ERP System, Project Management Software, or both?
How to harness synergies
Effective project management and efficient resource utilization play a crucial role for businesses aiming to enhance or sustain their competitiveness. Therefore, many of our clients are in search of solutions to optimize their project management processes. One question that frequently arises is why, in addition to an already established ERP system with fundamental project management features, a project management software could also be advantageous. In this blog post, we aim to comprehensively explore this important question and highlight the multifaceted reasons why such a combination can be a strategic decision for sustainable project success.
Differences in ERP system and Project Management Software functions
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems are software solutions designed to help companies efficiently plan and manage their resources. They provide functionalities for areas such as financial management, supply chain, human resources, production, procurement, sales, and more. Typically, ERP systems also offer some basic project management features, as projects are often part of a company’s business activities. These functionalities allow companies to plan project tasks, allocate resources, and track progress.
The fundamental project management features commonly found in many ERP systems include:
- Task and activity tracking: The ability to create, assign, and monitor tasks and activities related to projects.
- Time and resource management: The capability to capture and track time and resource usage in projects.
- Basic reporting: Generating simple reports on project progress, resource utilization, as well as budgeting.
- Budgeting and cost control: Managing project budgets, tracking expenses, and monitoring costs.
- Basic team communication: Functions for communication and collaboration within the project team.
However, there are also specialized ERP systems that focus more intensely on project management. These systems offer advanced features and tools that go beyond the basic project management functions in conventional ERP systems. They can be tailored specifically to the needs of project teams and enable enhanced project planning, monitoring, and control.
The fundamental differences between ERP systems with project management functionalities and standalone project management software lie in the specialization and depth of functionalities:
- Specialization: Project management software is designed to meet the specific requirements of projects. It provides comprehensive functionalities for project planning, resource allocation, progress tracking, risk management, reporting, and more.
- Flexibility: Project management software is often more flexible and adaptable to meet the individual requirements of various projects. For example, you can often choose whether to manage a project in a classical, agile, or hybrid manner.
- Collaboration: Project management software typically places a strong emphasis on team collaboration, communication, and shared information.
- Analysis and reporting: Standalone project management software often offers sophisticated analysis and reporting features to provide comprehensive insights into project metrics and performance.
The Limits of ERP Systems in Project Management
While an ERP system can be quite helpful for executing small projects, there are clear limits when it comes to effectively managing complex projects. Here are some of the challenges and limitations of using ERP systems in project management:
1. Lack of flexibility and adaptability:
Projects are unique, and no two projects are the same. They have their own requirements, timelines, resource needs, and challenges, which can also change during project implementation. However, ERP systems are typically designed to strictly follow standardized processes and business workflows. The high flexibility and adaptability that complex projects need to accommodate individual requirements, project structures, or workflows, are not provided by an ERP system. In contrast, standalone project management software allows flexible customization to the specific needs of each project. This means you are not forced to adapt your process to the software; instead, the software adapts to you. For instance, you can create tasks or workflows that mirror the exact sequence of your project, from task assignment to review and approval. This not only enhances efficiency but also minimizes the risk of misunderstandings or errors in project execution. Furthermore, due to its flexibility, project management software can grow with your company and its requirements. You can customize the software as your projects evolve or new challenges arise, ensuring that the software continues to meet your needs.
2. Emphasis on enterprise resources and financial management:
ERP systems are primarily geared toward optimizing resources like personnel, materials, and finances across the entire company. This means that project management in ERP systems is often considered part of overall resource planning. The specific requirements and complexity of individual projects can therefore often be inadequately captured. While project management software also allows real-time monitoring of budgets and costs, reports, for example, can show how expenses for a project are developing compared to the plan. These insights are crucial for detecting budget overruns early and taking countermeasures.
3. Challenges in tracking project workflows and progress:
Tracking and monitoring project workflows, milestones, tasks, and progress is a crucial part of project management. However, these functions are not adequately developed in many ERP systems. It can be difficult to get an overview of the current status of a project, identify bottlenecks or delays, and take appropriate actions promptly.
This could be because many ERP systems have predefined data fields and reporting options. Yet, in projects, capturing and analysing certain additional data can be crucial. In general, project management software allows you to create custom fields to collect the data relevant to your project. This enhances the accuracy of reporting and supports informed decision-making. Additionally, through clear progress displays, Gantt charts, and milestones, project management software enables all stakeholders to have a real-time overview of the project’s status. This enables immediate adjustments, such as when a resource bottleneck or overload becomes visible.
4. Challenges in team communication and collaboration:
Successful project management requires seamless collaboration and effective communication among project participants. Project management software also serves as a central hub for team communication. Discussions, updates, project documents, and questions can be collected in one place, minimizing the clutter of emails and chats, enhancing transparency, and facilitating team members in staying informed. However, ERP systems often offer limited options for team communication and collaboration, particularly when it comes to sharing project information, distributing documents, discussing tasks, or coordinating schedules. These limitations can hinder the efficiency and effectiveness of the project team.
Benefits of dedicated Project Management Software
Dedicated project management software offers a multitude of benefits compared to ERP systems with limited project management functionalities. Here are some of the key advantages that specialized project management software provides:
1. Focus on project planning, monitoring, and control:
Project management software is specifically designed to support project planning, monitoring, and control. It offers a comprehensive range of functionalities that allow defining project tasks, allocating resources, setting dependencies, establishing milestones, and tracking progress. This enables detailed and structured project planning, leading to more effective project execution.
2. Intuitive user interface and specialized features:
Furthermore, project management software often provides a user-friendly and intuitive interface, making it easier for project teams to perform their tasks. It offers specialized features like Gantt charts, Kanban boards, task lists, calendar views, or reporting tools. These features help project stakeholders to keep track of their tasks, prioritize, and identify bottlenecks.
3. Enhanced team collaboration and communication:
In addition, project management software promotes team collaboration and facilitates communication among project participants. It simplifies sharing project information, commenting on tasks, assigning responsibilities, and conducting discussions in a centralized location. Team members can collaborate easily, exchange information, and stay up-to-date on project status.
4. Tracking tasks, milestones, and resource allocation:
Tracking tasks, milestones, and resource allocation are integral parts of any project management software. This allows project managers to keep an eye on the progress of individual tasks, monitor milestone achievements, as well as efficiently plan and allocate resources. Additionally, gaining detailed insights into project progress helps identify bottlenecks or delays early and address them.
5. Extensive reporting and analysis capabilities:
Project management software also enables extensive reporting and analysis of project data. It offers a variety of customisable report formats that allow analysing project status, resource consumption, cost development, and other relevant metrics. These reports aid in evaluating project progress, making decisions, and continuously improving project management practices.
Synergies between Project Management Software and ERP Systems
Both ERP systems and project management software have their advantages and reasons for existence. Integrating project management software with an existing ERP system enables companies to harness the benefits of both systems and create synergies. Here are some ways in which both solutions complement each other and how companies can make optimal use of these synergies:
- Integration of data and information exchange: By integrating project management software and ERP systems, relevant data can be seamlessly exchanged. Project-related information, such as project budgets, resource availability, and costs, can be transferred from the ERP system to the project management software. Conversely, project data, like completed tasks, project status, and progress reports, can flow back into the ERP system. This creates a holistic view of project activities and enables better coordination between the systems.
- Utilization of ERP data for resource planning and management: An ERP system holds vital information about company resources such as personnel, materials, and finances. This data can be used in the project management software to perform realistic resource planning and management. By accessing real-time data from the ERP system, project managers can better estimate resource needs, avoid bottlenecks, and ensure efficient resource allocation.
- Synchronization of financial data for budgeting and cost control: Integrating project management software and ERP systems also facilitates improved budgeting and cost control. Financial data from the ERP system, such as budgets, costs, and accounting information, can be automatically transferred to the project management software. As a result, project managers gain a clear view of the project’s financial performance, can identify budget overruns, and take timely corrective actions.
- Optimization of business processes through the combination of both systems: Combining project management software and ERP systems enables companies to optimize their business processes. Through automatic data exchange and integration of relevant information, project and company data can be better aligned. This facilitates identifying dependencies, improves communication, and contributes to more efficient project execution. Companies can enhance and standardize their project management practices by implementing proven methods and processes in the project management software and linking them to the ERP systems.
Best practices for integrating Project Management Software and ERP Systems
Integrating project management software and ERP systems requires careful planning and implementation to achieve optimal results. Here are some best practices that companies should consider when integrating both systems:
- Select compatible systems with interface capabilities: When choosing project management software and an ERP system, it’s crucial to consider compatibility and available interface capabilities. Verify if the two systems can exchange data and integrate information seamlessly. Work closely with the providers to ensure smooth integration.
- Clearly define data flows and responsibilities: Defining clear data flow and responsibilities between the project management software and the ERP system is essential. Determine which data and information should be exchanged between the systems and who is responsible for maintaining and updating the respective data. This ensures that both systems are always up to date.
- Train employees for effective use of both systems: Thorough training of employees is crucial to ensure they can effectively use both the project management software and the ERP system. Provide training sessions and materials to familiarize employees with the features and capabilities of both systems. Raise awareness of the benefits of integration and show them how to optimize the use of the systems to perform their tasks efficiently.
- Regular review and adjustment of the integration: Successful integration requires regular review and adjustment. Monitor the performance of the integration to ensure smooth data flow and to achieve the desired outcomes. Make necessary adjustments as needed to enhance the integration and meet the changing requirements of the company.
- Ensure data security and compliance with privacy regulations: When integrating systems, it’s important to consider data security and applicable privacy regulations. Ensure that sensitive data is adequately protected and accessible only to authorized personnel. Implement security measures such as encryption, access controls, and regular data backups to ensure data integrity and confidentiality.
By adhering to these best practices, companies can ensure a seamless integration between project management software and ERP systems. This enables the effective use of both systems and enhances the overall efficiency of project management.
Especially for companies dealing with complex projects subject to changing requirements or needs, it makes sense to utilize project management software in addition to an ERP system. Integrating such software alongside your existing ERP system offers numerous advantages, allowing you to leverage the best of both worlds and create synergies. This enables efficient project execution, optimal resource utilization, and maintains precise control over project finances.
An ERP-integrated project management software like myPARM can assist you in planning, monitoring, and controlling projects, offering additional benefits such as integrated risk and opportunity management, comprehensive project reporting, as well as flexibility in handling complex projects.
Learn more about the project and portfolio management software myPARM:
Would you like to get to know myPARM in a demo presentation? Then make an appointment with us right away!