When project termination becomes inevitable

How to proceed when a project fails

What is project termination?

Project termination refers to the premature ending of a project before its objectives are achieved. It is important to differentiate between a temporary suspension and a definitive termination.

1. Project Suspension:

A suspension occurs when a project is temporarily put on hold but with the intention of resuming it at a later time. This can happen for various reasons, such as:

• Insufficient resources: If a project lacks adequate resources, such as budget, personnel, or technical equipment, a suspension may be necessary to acquire the missing resources.
• Delays: If a project is unable to adhere to its schedule due to unforeseen obstacles or complications, a temporary suspension can be considered to adjust the timeline and make necessary adaptations.
• External influences and force majeure events: Occasionally, external factors like political changes, legal regulations, natural disasters, wars and armed conflicts, economic crises, or technological developments may require a temporary suspension of the project to respond or adapt to these changes.
  External influences and force majeure primarily refer to events or circumstances beyond a person or organization’s control that can impact their activities, decisions, or obligations. These influences can be unpredictable and have significant effects on the normal functioning of businesses, governments, and other institutions.

2. Project Termination:

Definitive termination occurs when the decision is made that the project can or should no longer be continued. This can have various reasons, such as:

• Insurmountable obstacles: If a project encounters unforeseen or insurmountable obstacles that permanently prevent goal achievement or make the project’s costs and benefits unacceptable, definitive termination may be necessary.
• Lack of prospects for success: If it becomes evident that the project will not achieve its defined goals, even after extensive adjustments and efforts, definitive termination can be considered a reasonable decision.
• Changed priorities: Sometimes, a company or organization’s priorities change, rendering the project no longer aligned with current strategic objectives. In such cases, termination may be necessary to free up resources for other projects.

Factors leading to unavoidable project termination

Factors leading to project termination can be diverse and vary depending on the project and circumstances. Here are some common factors that can lead to project termination:

• Insufficient resources: If a project lacks sufficient financial means, personnel, equipment, or other resources to achieve its goals, termination may become unavoidable. Continuing the project under these circumstances would likely result in quality deficiencies, time delays, and ultimately project failure. If the resource shortage is severe and you are unable to save enough resources or obtain additional resources, project termination may be inevitable. The same applies, for example, if a significant portion of the budget has already been spent, and further financial means are needed, causing the cost-benefit ratio to become unbalanced.
• Delays: If a project is unable to adhere to its schedule and experiences delays, serious consequences can arise. If the delays are significant to the point where the project goals cannot be achieved within acceptable limits or if the delays significantly undermine the project’s business value, project termination may be necessary. Additionally, if the project result becomes irrelevant due to late completion, for example, because a competitor brings a similar product to the market faster in this case, and accelerating the project may only be possible at enormous costs, it may no longer be financially viable to continue with such a project and it should be aborted.
• Unforeseen risks and obstacles: Especially in very long-term projects, unforeseen risks and obstacles sometimes arise during project implementation, significantly affecting the project. These risks and obstacles can be of a technical, economic, legal, or organizational nature. If these risks and obstacles cannot be successfully overcome or their impact is significant, project termination may be the best option to avoid further damage.
• Failure to achieve project objectives: If a project, despite extensive efforts and significant resource allocation, cannot achieve its defined objectives, project termination should also be considered. This may be due to unrealistic goal setting, changing requirements, insufficient feasibility studies, or the project not delivering the expected benefits.

Determining when project termination is no longer avoidable depends on the combination of these factors and the overall evaluation of the project. It is often the case that various factors occur simultaneously, for example, when the feasibility was unclear at the beginning of a project, causing both time and cost/resource overruns. The question now arises as to how long one should try to salvage a project and at what point it should be terminated. Usually, project termination becomes unavoidable when:

• The project costs significantly exceed the financial resources of the company, and there is no possibility of obtaining additional funding.
• The delays are so significant that the project can no longer achieve its business or strategic objectives, and the resulting loss of value is unacceptable.
• The risks and obstacles are so substantial that successful project implementation is no longer realistic, and the potential negative impacts are unacceptable.
• The project has continuously failed to achieve its defined objectives over an extended period, with no realistic prospect of achieving these goals in the near future.

In such cases, project termination is often the most reasonable decision to concentrate resources, time, and energy on other projects with better chances of success. However, you should also consider that aspects of a project may potentially be implemented in a smaller or new project, or it may be worthwhile to completely redesign a project and redefine the set goals.

How to identify early signs of project termination?

To take timely action and avoid investing important resources in a project that needs to be terminated, it is crucial to recognize the early signs of project termination. Additionally, the failure of a project can be more difficult to handle the longer the project has been implemented and the more resources have been invested. The reputational damage caused by project termination also increases the longer a project lasts. Here are some approaches and indicators that can help identify an inevitable project termination:

• Regular project progress review: Continuous monitoring of project progress allows for the early identification of potential issues or delays. This includes regular status meetings, project reports, and tracking of milestones and tasks. For example, if you notice that important milestones or objectives are consistently delayed, despite taking appropriate measures and adjustments, it may be a sign that the project should be terminated. The same applies if you encounter significant risks and obstacles during project implementation that you cannot overcome.
• Analysis of performance indicators and metrics: Using performance indicators and metrics enables an objective assessment of project progress. This can include analysing cost variances, schedules, quality standards, or customer feedback. If established indicators consistently fall short of expectations, this can be a warning sign. Therefore, if you notice significant cost overruns that cannot be offset by additional financial resources, it is an important indicator of project failure. The same applies if you observe a continuous decline in quality or customer satisfaction but are unable to address the underlying issues.
• Stakeholder communication and feedback: Involving stakeholders and obtaining regular feedback is also crucial. By engaging in dialogue with stakeholders, including the project team, customers, management, and other interest groups, potential problems or challenges can be identified early on. If you notice that you are losing support from key stakeholders, it can also be an indication that a project should be terminated.

However, recognizing one of these signs alone is not sufficient to justify project termination. Instead, a thorough analysis and assessment of the situation, as well as informed decision-making, are necessary to determine whether project termination is truly unavoidable and what steps should be taken next.

Decision-making process and implementation of project termination

The decision-making process for project termination should be conducted carefully to ensure that all relevant factors are taken into account. Here is a step-by-step guide to the decision-making process:

1. Identification of issues and challenges:

It is important to identify problems, risks, or obstacles that could jeopardize the successful completion of the project early on. This way, you can accurately analyse and weigh the nature, severity, and impact of the problems on the project objectives.

2. Evaluation of project benefits and goals:

Additionally, you should assess whether the project can still achieve the intended goals and expected benefits. So, evaluate the current value of the project compared to the original expectations and goals.

3. Analysis of resource availability:

Review the availability and need for financial, personnel, or technical resources. Are there sufficient resources to successfully complete the project, or would they require disproportionately high costs?

4. Stakeholder analysis:

Also, consider the interests and opinions of stakeholders, including the project team, customers, management, and other relevant parties. It may be the case that a project should technically be terminated, but it needs to be continued for strategic or image reasons.

5. Risk assessment:

A comprehensive risk assessment helps you understand the potential impacts of problems, delays, or other challenges. Evaluate the likelihood and severity of these risks and whether they are manageable or not. Uncontrollable risks from external influences and force majeure should be particularly considered and are often included in contracts as well as legal agreements with corresponding clauses to protect the contracting parties from the effects of such unforeseeable events. These clauses may lead to obligations or contracts being temporarily or permanently terminated if fulfilment becomes impossible or unreasonable due to such influences or events.

6. Cost-benefit analysis:

A cost-benefit analysis helps you evaluate the financial implications of project termination compared to continuing the project. Consider both the direct costs and the long-term impact on the company. For example, it may occur that a project can no longer be implemented due to high costs and insufficient resources, but project termination would not be financially viable for the company. In such a case, you will have to bite the bullet and push through the project despite the additional effort.

Examination of alternatives and courses of action:

Before terminating a project, consider all possible alternatives, such as adjusting the project scope, goals, or timeline. Evaluate these options in terms of feasibility, impact, and prospects of success to make an informed decision.

8. Decision-making:

Based on the previous steps and the gathered information, you can now make an informed decision about project termination. Weigh all the aforementioned points carefully against each other. Additionally, consider whether parts of the project that have already been implemented can be utilized elsewhere or if the lessons learned can be transferred to other projects.

9. Communication:

Once you have decided to terminate the project, it is important to communicate this decision clearly and transparently to all relevant stakeholders. For extensive projects with numerous stakeholders, creating a communication plan can be helpful, where you define the target audiences, key messages, as well as communication channels. Ensure that you explain the reasons for your decision and the underlying factors based on facts, without resorting to blame. Also, explain how the project termination will impact different stakeholder groups and outline the measures that will be taken. Since your project team will be particularly affected by the project termination, make sure to involve your team from the beginning and provide them with the opportunity to ask questions. Clarify responsibilities for implementing the project termination so that all involved parties know what is expected of them.

10. Implementation:

Subsequently, take the necessary actions to terminate the project and ensure an orderly closure. Complete any remaining tasks, document the project status, and archive relevant documents. Additionally, when terminating a project, it is important to adhere to existing contracts, agreements, or legal frameworks to be legally compliant.

11. Learning and improvement:

After project termination, conducting a retrospective evaluation and drawing lessons from the project is crucial. This allows you to learn from mistakes, better plan future projects, identify risks early on and optimize processes.

Conclusion

Early recognition of signs indicating an inevitable project termination is crucial to take appropriate actions in a timely manner. Continuous monitoring of project progress, analysis of performance indicators, consideration of stakeholder feedback, and thorough risk assessment help identify potential issues quickly.

Utilizing project management software such as myPARM can facilitate monitoring and evaluation of project progress by providing a clear overview of tasks, resources, timelines and goals, as well as identifying risks. This enables the early detection and proactive management of irregularities and delays to avoid project terminations or minimize their impact.
Overall, it is important to take signs of an unavoidable project termination seriously and act accordingly. Thorough analysis, informed decision-making, clear communication, and orderly implementation are essential for effectively managing project terminations.

Learn more about the project and portfolio management software myPARM:

Would you like to get to know myPARM in a demo presentation? Then make an appointment with us right away!